Overview
Vacancy, expenses and net operating income are the core components of income based valuation for residential investment properties.
They determine how well a property performs, how much risk it carries and what kind of return an investor can expect.
Appraisers rely on these factors to determine market value and to ensure that income projections align with investor behaviour across the GTA and surrounding areas.
This guide breaks down how vacancy, expenses and net operating income influence valuation and why they matter so much to both investors and lenders.
These three items directly affect:
• Cap rate analysis
• Income approach value
• Lender underwriting
• Risk assessment
• Borrower qualification
• Investment decision making
Understanding them gives investors a clear picture of whether a property is priced correctly and how it compares to other income properties in the market.
Vacancy represents the portion of time a unit is not generating rent.
Appraisers and lenders consider vacancy because it reflects operational risk.
- Market Vacancy Rate
Appraisers evaluate local vacancy patterns using:
• Rental market reports
• Local demand trends
• Historical performance
• Comparable rental properties
Low vacancy means strong rental demand.
High vacancy signals risk that affects both income and value.
- Building Specific Vacancy
Appraisers also consider the property’s own rental history.
Factors include:
• How long units typically stay vacant
• How quickly units lease at market rent
• Whether vacancy is seasonal
• Whether vacancy is caused by condition issues
A long vacancy history raises concerns about demand or pricing.
- How Vacancy Impacts Valuation
Vacancy reduces effective rental income.
The higher the vacancy rate, the lower the net operating income and the lower the possible value.
Understanding Expenses
Expenses reduce the income available to investors.
Appraisers analyze actual expenses and compare them to market norms.
Typical Operating Expenses Include:
- • Property taxes
• Insurance
• Utilities
• Repairs and maintenance
• Property management fees
• Cleaning and turnover costs
• Landscaping and snow removal
• Vacancy impact
• Pest control
• Waste removal
- Market Supported Expenses
Appraisers use expense ratios supported by local investor behaviour.
If the seller underreports expenses, appraisers adjust using market benchmarks.
- Why Accurate Expenses Matter
Understated expenses lead to inflated net operating income and unrealistic value.
Overstated expenses reduce the income approach value unnecessarily.
Understanding Net Operating Income
Net operating income (NOI) is the backbone of income based valuation. Formula: NOI = Gross Rental Income minus Operating Expenses Appraisers rely on NOI to determine value through the income approach.
- Determine Market Rent
Both actual and market rent are reviewed.
- Apply Market Vacancy Rate
Vacancy reduces gross income to reflect risk.
- Deduct Market Supported Expenses
Appraisers apply realistic expense ratios to avoid inflated NOI.
- Calculate NOI
NOI represents the property’s true income potential.
- Apply the Appropriate Cap Rate
Cap rates reflect risk, location and demand.
- Cross Check with Comparable Sales
The final value must align with investor behaviour in the area.
“If tenants pay their own utilities, NOI doubles.”
Not always. Other expenses still apply and cap rates adjust accordingly.
“Low expenses mean higher value.”
Only if the expense profile is realistic and market supported.
“Vacancy does not apply if I have long term tenants.”
Appraisers still apply a vacancy allowance to reflect market risk.
“NOI equals cash flow.”
NOI is before financing. Cash flow depends on mortgage structure.
Do appraisers use actual expenses or market expenses?
Both, but market supported expenses often carry more weight for valuation.
How much vacancy do appraisers apply?
It depends on neighbourhood trends, property type and unit demand.
Can below market rent affect NOI?
Yes. Appraisers often use market rent to avoid undervaluing the property.
Do lenders accept NOI calculations from appraisers?
Lenders review them but may apply their own underwriting rules.
If you want a clear breakdown of vacancy, expenses and NOI for your investment property, our appraisal team can provide an income based valuation that reflects current investor expectations in your neighbourhood.
© Copyright Advanced Appraisals
